I’ve hunted down and read people’s comments on a lot of different sites about the Notre Dame fire and its restoration. Most of it is supportive, but there are a few fellow Christians (and others of course) out there hung up on the money it will take to restore Notre Dame, and the fact that “it’s just a building.” I do my best to empathize with my fellow human beings, especially when there is a dearth of that on the interweb, so I do get the point they are making, but they are missing The Point of structures like Notre Dame.
Yes, it will take loads of cash to rebuild the Lady, yes, that cash could go elsewhere (I suggest putting your cash wherever you like if it bothers you so much, and make sure you are eating beans and rice, and not anything more expensive so you can give even more money to your causes), but do you seriously think that a structure is all that the money is going toward? What good are buildings anyway? Does God disapprove of buildings? Of beauty? Of Architecture?
We already know from Art Appreciation 101 that the human eye, hence the human mind finds certain ratios, and shapes pleasing. It evokes something in us at a level that we are hardly aware of. There are many articles out now about the impact of architecture on the human brain, even neurobiologically speaking. Interesting isn’t it? I don’t think God does anything frivolously, especially in the laying down of laws or guidance, so all of those structures he ordered humans to build in very specific ways can’t have been capricious. We are not Gnostics; the physical world (including our bodies) started out good, we are physical beings, and after the resurrection we will have perfected physical bodies. The physical is important, it always has been since the beginning.
God even gave specific instruction dealing with physical things all the time, including buildings. The way He instructed the Jewish tribes to arrange their camp, the instructions for the tent, and then the temple. Noah’s ark, the ark of the covenant, and Nehushtan the bronze serpent. God knows us and our minds because He made us and He recognizes the need we have for physical-ness. No, He is not limited to physical place and clearly when Jesus walked the earth, was crucified, and resurrected things did change, but there was never a proscribed ban on buildings built to hold worshipers.
Notre Dame was built with worship directed toward God. The artisans and workers poured themselves into it and made their praise physically manifest. The windows were the Gospel writ large in living color. Symbols are important, they are not impotent signs, but rather something that has taken on the true essence of the thing it represents. Symbols have power.
There are people that owe their belief in God to capitulating to His call put forth in beauty. People have felt His call in churches, before great works of art, or listening to music. I know the stories of people who were agnostic, but upon traveling to all the great old cathedrals in Europe said they came away knowing He existed, and have followed Him since. When humans allow God to work through us, or to inspire us, the result can be a glimpse of heaven. We can definitely see that in nature as well, but when we see something that comes from the effort of a group of humans working together to build instead of destroy… well, we recognize a truth in that. Civilization. Civilization directed toward God and in His service. That’s important.